More than six billion people worldwide now use social media, and a growing body of research links heavy use among children to anxiety, depression, bullying and exploitation. Australia has responded with the most sweeping legal experiment yet: a nationwide requirement that platforms like Snapchat, TikTok and Instagram take "reasonable steps" to keep users under 16 off their services entirely. The law, which took effect late last year, is being watched closely by governments from London to Ottawa, because it could reshape what adolescence looks like for an entire generation.
In the United States, the response to social media's harms has largely played out in courtrooms and congressional hearings, with tech executives facing public apologies and companies settling lawsuits worth billions of dollars without admitting wrongdoing. Australia chose legislation instead. The policy originated in South Australia, where state premier Peter Malinauskas, pushed by his wife's concerns about teenagers losing control of their own phone habits, proposed a state-level ban that the federal government quickly adopted with bipartisan backing.
Malinauskas has been candid that the law is not meant to eliminate teenage social media use entirely, comparing it to underage drinking or smoking: kids will find workarounds, but a legal standard still changes behavior at the margins. His argument is also philosophical. He describes social media platforms as engines of "social engineering," algorithmically shaping what young people see for profit, with no public oversight - a dynamic he believes justifies government intervention.
Australia's online safety regulator reported that in the law's first three months, the share of 10- to 15-year-olds holding accounts on age-restricted platforms fell by roughly a fifth. But enforcement has been inconsistent. Around half of under-16 users who kept their accounts said no one had even asked them to verify their age. Some teenagers simply created new profiles with falsified birth dates; others found that platforms using facial-scanning technology to estimate age let them through regardless.
Julie Inman Grant, the government's eSafety commissioner and a former Microsoft and Twitter employee, is now investigating several platforms for possible non-compliance, with potential penalties running into tens of millions of dollars per violation. She argues that reputational damage, more than fines, may be what ultimately pushes companies to comply - and claims some firms have spent more effort lobbying other governments against similar laws than building the verification tools needed to meet Australia's own standard.
The human stakes behind the policy are stark. Wayne Holdsworth, whose teenage son took his own life after being blackmailed over an intimate photo sent to someone posing online as a peer, now tours Australian schools warning about the risks of unsupervised access. He sees the ban as government finally fulfilling its duty to protect children from platforms operating largely unchecked.
Not everyone agrees. Teenager Noah Jones, who openly circumvented the age checks, is a witness in a legal challenge before Australia's High Court arguing the law infringes on the right to political communication. He describes social media as "the modern town square" and warns that excluding young people from it puts them at an informational disadvantage - a tension between protection and access that lawmakers elsewhere will have to confront.
The companies themselves insist they are complying while defending their broader approach. Meta has argued that blanket bans risk pushing teenagers toward unregulated, less safe corners of the internet. Snap disputes claims that its product is designed to be addictive or prioritizes profit over safety. TikTok says safety is built into its platform's design. Whether any of this satisfies regulators remains unresolved, but the policy's influence is already spreading: the United Kingdom's own restrictions are due to take effect next year, and Norway, Spain and Canada are drafting comparable measures. Australia's experiment, messy enforcement and all, may end up setting the template the rest of the world follows - or the cautionary tale it chooses to avoid.